按年被提到
20192023 · 22 次2026
开源书›软件工程·No.37

Shape Up: Stop Running in Circles and Ship Work that Matters

Shape Up:停止原地打转,交付真正重要的工作
Ryan Singer

Basecamp 的产品开发方法:六周周期、赌注与按预算做方案

免费阅读 ↗
被推荐 · 87 人首次 2019-07-09 · 最近 2026-07-24官方免费在线(版权保留,作者或出版社免费放出)
87不同的人
54活跃月份
23有推荐的月份
102讨论串

Ryan Singer 介绍 Basecamp 的产品开发流程:先把工作塑形(shaping),再用有限的预算(appetite)和固定的六周周期交给小团队完成,并以演示和冷却期收尾。书的篇幅不长,以概念和例子为主,没有代码或练习。和常见的敏捷或 Scrum 资料相比,它不鼓励做工时估算,也不鼓励一开始就列满工单。

HN 为什么推荐它

HN 上的人推荐它适合小团队,认为它篇幅短、质量高,用预算取代估算、放权给团队、塑形工作等想法很有启发;也有人把它当作对 Jira 式流程的另一种思路。

难度 2 / 5约 6 小时
适合谁

做产品或带小团队的工程师与经理

怎么读

由 Claude 根据这本书和 HN 上的说法整理,可能有错
  1. 1从第一部分塑形读起,这是整套方法的核心
  2. 2整本书不长,建议一口气通读,再回头细看自己团队用得上的部分
  3. 3读完把方法和自己团队现在的流程对比,挑一两点先试
  4. 4大团队的读者注意它是针对小团队写的,要自行取舍

HN 书评

推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每本最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及 · 作者本人贴的不算
强烈推荐bushido · 2019-07

“Highly recommend it if any of this resonates, high recommend if it doesn't and you want more ammo for a flame war.”

强烈推荐,称它是小团队成功规划的快速读物
A personal story about 10× development原评论 ↗
强烈推荐gls2ro · 2021-01

“I strongly recommend ShapeUp (see details here Shape Up)”

强烈推荐它,涉及六周周期、pitch 和小团队的 shaping
Ask HN: What are up-to-date methods for software development?原评论 ↗
强烈推荐vladstudio · 2021-12

“If you're intereseted in the topic, I highly recommend investing some time and reading it.”

强烈推荐感兴趣的人花时间读,涉及里程碑式项目规划
Great engineering teams focus on milestones instead of projects原评论 ↗
强烈推荐articsputnik · 2023-04

“Shape Up by Basecamp is the best resource I've seen on that topic.”

称它是该话题最好的资料,讲让小型整合团队全权负责工作
How to be a -10x Engineer原评论 ↗
强烈推荐distortionfield · 2023-12

“I would highly recommend reading the Shape Up Methodology from Basecamp if this interested you:”

强烈推荐,称它是简短、高质量、易消化的项目方法论
I make OKRs more playful for my team using Hill-Charts原评论 ↗
推荐cjcenizal · 2020-03

“A great read for anyone interested in simple, pragmatic, and effective approaches to shipping software.”

推荐它给想要简单务实高效交付软件的人
Not delivering end-user value原评论 ↗
看全部 20 条 →
推荐kot-behemoth · 2020-05

“Plus, their writeup on imagined vs discovered tasks and how Jira et al give false sense of control when creating tickets upfront is also illuminating: Shape Up”

引它说明 Jira 式预先建票给人虚假的掌控感
Show HN: Tara – A smart and free alternative to Jira原评论 ↗
推荐255kb · 2020-10

“Basecamp's latest book "Shape up" helped me a lot finding it.”

说它帮自己找到规格说明过多与过少之间的平衡
How much specification does a developer need?原评论 ↗
推荐serial_dev · 2021-03

“But the books is full of gems, so my two sentence overview doesn't do it justice. Read it here Shape Up”

推荐它,称全书精华很多,核心是从工作量估算转向 appetite
Ask HN: Do you think Agile/Scrum is beneficial for software delivery?原评论 ↗
推荐rambambram · 2021-04

“Somehow I keep coming back at the 'work is like a hill' metaphor from Ryan Singer in his book Shape Up (from basecamp).”

总想起书中“工作像一座山”的比喻
Computer Science from the Bottom Up原评论 ↗
推荐stepbeek · 2021-06

“I really like the approach that Basecamp recommend in Shape Up[1] where the team pivots to reasoning about work in terms of appetitie rather than expected time.”

喜欢它用 appetite 而非预估时间来思考工作
Software estimation is hard – do it anyway原评论 ↗
推荐shavin47 · 2021-11

“Hey dude, please check this out. Basecamp had a similar issue but the underlying cause was very simple and was fixable within a day.”

以 Basecamp 为例,说明类似的权限问题原因很简单、一天内可修好
How do you build a bare minimum feature?原评论 ↗
推荐adamqureshi · 2022-05

“read this: Shape Up”

让人读它,了解创业与商业方面的经验
Ask HN: Important nonobvious startup/business lessons you've learned?原评论 ↗
推荐sumanthvepa · 2022-07

“One book I came across, that I found interesting, was 'Shape Up' from Basecamp[1]. The ideas around shaping the work that needs to be done are interesting.”

觉得它关于早期模糊规划阶段 shaping 工作的想法很有意思
Ask HN: Can you share insights on developing or participating in project teams?原评论 ↗
推荐cybadger · 2022-08

“Part 1 of Basecamp's book "Shape Up" might be helpful too. It's not explicitly about specs, which is probably why I didn't think of it before, but it's worth a skim.”

建议略读第一部分,对写规格说明也有帮助
Ask HN: How to Write a Specification?原评论 ↗
推荐andrei_says_ · 2023-06

“You may want to look at Basecamp’s Shape Up.”

建议看看它,小而独立的团队、六周周期、不做微观管理
Agile is people, the rest is commentary原评论 ↗
推荐agloe_dreams · 2023-07

“So, for some adversarial reading, I recommend taking a look at:”

推荐它作为对立视角的阅读,提供规划和完成工作的另一种方式
Ask HN: Do Agile 'Sprints' Benefit Software Developers?原评论 ↗
推荐CharlieDigital · 2023-09

“I recommend it for any team that wants some sanity in the processes.”

推荐给想让流程更理智的团队,兼顾可预测性与工作生活平衡
“Waterfall” doesn't mean what you think it means原评论 ↗
推荐phtevenf · 2024-09

“For those interested here's a link to it Shape Up.”

给出链接,介绍基于 appetite 的规划、六周周期和 cooldown
Why Scrum is stressing you out原评论 ↗
推荐mindcrash · 2025-02

“Ryan Singer - the inventor of the methodology - has written a really great book about how they have been, and currently are, building and shipping products and features at 37signals.”

推荐 Ryan Singer 这本书,讲 37signals 如何构建和交付产品
Product Development Processes You Might Not Have Heard of (2022)原评论 ↗