按年被提到
20082011 · 7 次2026
开源书›编程语言·No.20

Thinking Forth

Thinking Forth:Forth 编程思维
Leo Brodie

借 Forth 讲程序设计思想:分解、命名、简洁与可维护

免费阅读 ↗
被推荐 · 41 人首次 2008-08-01 · 最近 2026-04-19许可证 CC BY-NC-SA 2.0
41不同的人
57活跃月份
38有推荐的月份
63讨论串

Leo Brodie 的这本书以 Forth 语言为载体,讲软件设计的思考方式,包括如何分解问题、给词(word)命名、保持代码简短易维护,以及何时用 Forth 构建领域专用语言。书中用漫画式插图和大量例子说明,内容并不局限于 Forth,对其他语言的程序员也有启发。它是 Starting Forth 的进阶读物,偏重设计而非语法。书写于较早年代,部分细节已显得陈旧。

HN 为什么推荐它

HN 上很多人说它改变了自己写程序的方式,即使没怎么写过 Forth 也值得读;常被称作关于设计与简洁的好书,也被推荐用来理解基于栈的语言的思维模型。有人提醒其中部分信息已经过时。

难度 3 / 5约 12 小时开放许可
适合谁

对程序设计思想感兴趣的程序员

读之前最好知道
1任意编程语言基础
2Forth 基础语法

怎么读

由 Claude 根据这本书和 HN 上的说法整理,可能有错
  1. 1完全没接触过 Forth,先读 Starting Forth 或了解基本语法
  2. 2把重点放在设计与分解的思想上,不必纠结具体实现
  3. 3读的时候想想这些原则如何用到自己常用的语言里
  4. 4过时的部分略读即可

HN 书评

推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每本最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及 · 作者本人贴的不算
强烈推荐arakyd · 2009-08

“My favorite book of this type is Thinking Forth, available online at Thinking Forth.”

称它是这类书里自己最爱的一本,可在线读
Hacking a Google Interview - MIT's guide to Google interviews原评论 ↗
强烈推荐jacobolus · 2012-02

“For anyone who’s never read it, I strongly recommend Thinking Forth.”

强烈推荐没读过的人读
Why Concatenative Programming Matters原评论 ↗
强烈推荐pandaman · 2013-04

“Actually, Forth (the predecessor of concatenate languages) has the best tutorials I've ever read - Starting Forth and Thinking Forth by Leo Brodie.”

称它和 Starting Forth 是读过最好的教程
Factor 0.96 now available – over 1,100 commits原评论 ↗
强烈推荐fogus · 2016-07

“"Thinking Forth" by Leo Brodie --> Thinking Forth”

把它列为对自己职业生涯影响最大的三本书之一
Ask HN: What three books impacted your career the most?原评论 ↗
强烈推荐mikekchar · 2017-07

“Thinking Forth. Nearly 35 years later it still probably dominates my approach.”

说近 35 年后它仍基本主导自己的做法
Ask HN: What books had the greatest effect on how you structure your code?原评论 ↗
强烈推荐haolez · 2018-05

“I highly recommend the book "Thinking Forth"”

强烈推荐这本书
Fif, a stack-based scripting language原评论 ↗
看全部 20 条 →
推荐silentbicycle · 2008-08

“If you're interested in Forth, check out the online Thinking Forth book project: Thinking Forth”

向对 Forth 感兴趣的人推荐在线的 Thinking Forth 项目
The Evolution of Forth (1993)原评论 ↗
推荐triplefox · 2009-02

“I'd add the book "Thinking Forth", which I just read again recently:”

补充推荐 Thinking Forth,自己最近刚重读
Papers Every Programmer Should Read原评论 ↗
推荐spc476 · 2009-03

“It was one of two books that really affected how I program and even though it's about Forth (and I've never really did much Forth programming), it's worth reading.”

说它深刻影响了自己的编程方式,没写过 Forth 也值得读
Parsing Roman Numbers - Beautifully原评论 ↗
推荐RodgerTheGreat · 2011-02

“Read Starting Forth[2] for a gentle introduction to the language and Thinking Forth[3] for an in-depth examination of the idioms and patterns of Forth programming.”

先读 Starting Forth 入门,再读它深入了解 Forth 惯用法
Forth vs Lisp原评论 ↗
推荐fizfaz · 2013-06

“I learned a lot from this book.”

说自己从这本书里学到很多
Starting Forth – the classic Forth language tutorial原评论 ↗
推荐yetfeo · 2014-01

“One of the best development books I've read is Thinking Forth [1].”

称它是读过最好的开发类书籍之一
Best development book I've read, has no code in it原评论 ↗
推荐alex4nder · 2014-08

“It's a good read even if you never intend to build a forth project.”

说即使不打算做 Forth 项目也值得一读
The Beautiful Simplicity of ColorForth (2013)原评论 ↗
推荐i336_ · 2016-02

“you may also be interested in Thinking Forth and (链接)”

给想学 Forth 的人补充推荐
Ask HN: What (obscure?) areas of tech are engaging, sane, and incredibly stable?原评论 ↗
推荐progman · 2016-06

“You should read Leo Brodie's book "Thinking Forth".”

建议读 Brodie 的这本书
The J1 Forth CPU (2010)原评论 ↗
推荐tbirdz · 2016-09

“I'd also recommend looking at Thinking Forth if you want to get some more insight into Forth's philosophy, and really program structuring in general.”

推荐它来了解 Forth 的理念和通用的程序结构
Plan9 from?原评论 ↗
推荐Jach · 2017-07

“though I remembered there's this if you want an idea of the philosophy Thinking Forth”

想了解 Forth 的理念可以看它
How I got banned from Codewars原评论 ↗
推荐protomyth · 2017-11

“Thinking Forth is a pretty good starting point and in general a great programming book Thinking Forth”

称它是不错的 Forth 入门,也是很棒的编程书
Chuck Moore, Extreme Programmer原评论 ↗
推荐carapace · 2018-08

“You'd have to read "Thinking Forth" by Brodie”

说想理解 stack-based 语言的思维模型就得读它
Factor: An impressive stack-based language environment原评论 ↗
批评pietrofmaggi · 2010-09

“So this kind of information is a bit dated.”

批评书里这类信息有些过时
Forth versus C原评论 ↗