批评joe_the_user · 2009-12
“it doesn't read like something that would be published in a serious journal whether it's correct or not.”
声称证伪大气温室效应的争议论文,HN 上被视为伪科学
论文声称依据热力学第二定律等物理原理,大气温室效应只是虚构的机制,并列出六点理由,例如平均地表温度无法计算、33 摄氏度的温差是错误算出的无意义数字、辐射平衡假设不物理等。这一结论与主流气候科学相悖,不是公认的结果。
HN 上的人提它多是作为反面例子,称它不像能在严肃期刊发表的论文,是 crackpot(伪科学)论文的典型。
“it doesn't read like something that would be published in a serious journal whether it's correct or not.”
“the complete crackpot papers (like this one: Falsification Of The Atmospheric CO2 Greenhouse Effects Within The Frame Of Physics) are in the second category.”