按年被提到
20092020 · 4 次2026
物理与量子›曲速引擎与黑洞物理·arXiv:0908.1803 · gr-qc

Are Black Hole Starships Possible

黑洞星舰有可能吗?
Louis Crane, Shawn Westmoreland · 2009

探讨以人造黑洞霍金辐射为动力的星舰

开始阅读 ↗PDFalphaXiv 讨论
被推荐 · 13 人首次 2009-12-01 · 最近 2025-11-27
13不同的人
19活跃月份
19讨论串
9被引(OpenAlex)

探讨能否利用人造黑洞的霍金辐射作为能源,建造星舰或动力源。结论是该设想处在可能性的边缘,而量子引力效应可能改变这一图景。

HN 为什么提它

每当有关于星际旅行或能源的文章出现,评论者就拿它作为有趣的思想实验,说明微型黑洞作为无反作用质量推进的动力源在物理上似乎并不被禁止。

观点难度 4 / 5约 40 分钟经得起时间
读之前最好知道
1霍金辐射与黑洞热力学
2广义相对论基础
3火箭推进与比冲
4量子引力的基本概念

HN 书评

推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及
推荐Detrus · 2011-06

“Most of their science paper is in layman English Are Black Hole Starships Possible and explains such questions.”

推荐,用通俗英文解释如何造出微型黑洞
Why we are unlikely to ever leave the solar system.原评论 ↗
推荐throwawaytire · 2016-08

“Whenever one of these articles comes out I like to think of this fun paper:”

每逢相关文章出现就想起这篇有趣的黑洞星舰论文
Sad Trombone Exoplanet Reality Check原评论 ↗
推荐jessaustin · 2019-09

“This paper has some interesting ideas.”

推荐这篇论文,称其中以微型黑洞为星舰引擎和燃料的想法有意思
Water found on a potentially life-friendly alien planet原评论 ↗
引用cletus · 2011-06

“The far-fetched version is to use back holes as power sources [1] as this is, as far as I've read anyway, the only remotely viable method of providing propulsion without reaction mass to speak of”

拿它说明黑洞可以作为星舰的动力源,几乎无需反应质量
Why we are unlikely to ever leave the solar system.原评论 ↗
引用kristianp · 2011-12

“Microscopic black holes have been theorized as power sources for starships.”

指出微型黑洞在理论上被设想为星舰的动力源
Sending a spacecraft to Alpha Centauri原评论 ↗
引用kristianp · 2014-01

“We are only centuries of progress away from this: "Are Black Hole Starships Possible", Are Black Hole Starships Possible”

调侃距离实现黑洞星舰只差几个世纪的进步
Antimatter experiment produces first beam of antihydrogen原评论 ↗
看全部 18 条 →
引用adrianN · 2014-03

“This seems to by allowed by the laws of physics according to this paper:”

引它说明这件事按物理定律看是允许的,涉及人造黑洞的 Hawking 辐射供能
The Challenge of Relativistic Spaceflight原评论 ↗
引用ceequof · 2015-04

“Are Black Hole Starships Possible (See the table on page 15)”

引用论文第 15 页表格里黑洞寿命和尺寸的数字
First 26 pages of Neal Stephenson's new novel Seveneves原评论 ↗
引用adrianN · 2019-03

“[1] Section V of this paper Are Black Hole Starships Possible”

指向论文第 V 节,讨论制造微型黑洞用于星际旅行的可行性
Rotating Black Holes May Serve as Gentle Portals for Hyperspace Travel原评论 ↗
引用sbierwagen · 2019-11

“it'll be radiating super-energetic x-rays at (an average) 1.57 giga-electronvolts each.”

借小黑洞蒸发的物理说明它会辐射高能 X 射线,讨论能否驱动星舰
New type of black holes – Non interacting low-mass black hole原评论 ↗
引用kristianp · 2020-01

“where results about quantum gravity can be gained [1].”

引它讨论小黑洞能否供能,并能借此获得量子引力方面的结果
Musings on the Current Status of High Energy Physics原评论 ↗
引用adrianN · 2020-02

“The best way I know is creating small artificial black holes, feeding them matter at just the right rate and harvesting the Hawking radiation.”

引它支持一个办法:造小型人造黑洞,适量喂物质,收集 Hawking 辐射
ESO telescope sees surface of dim Betelgeuse原评论 ↗
引用adrianN · 2020-05

“pretty good matter-to-energy converters:”

引它说明黑洞是相当好的物质转能量装置
Experts Doubt the Sun Is Burning Coal (1863)原评论 ↗
引用adrianN · 2020-11

“If the assumptions there are not wrong, and climate change doesn't get us first”

引它讨论制造微型黑洞,前提是其假设没有错
The Black Hole information loss problem is unsolvable原评论 ↗
引用sbierwagen · 2021-08

“Crane and Westmoreland looked into this”

指出 Crane 和 Westmoreland 研究过用伽马射线激光造小黑洞来推进
A Dyson sphere around a black hole原评论 ↗
引用sbierwagen · 2021-08

“See Are Black Hole Starships Possible”

引它说明黑洞驱动的工程难题很难但并非不可能
A Dyson sphere around a black hole原评论 ↗
引用blincoln · 2022-05

“I skimmed over Crane and Westmoreland's paper[1] and an article that discusses specific designs[2], and I'm still unsure how one would keep the vehicle and black hole moving together while also generating thrust.”

读了论文仍不明白如何让飞船与黑洞同步移动并产生推力
Can we make a black hole? And if we could, what could we do with it?原评论 ↗
引用octaane · 2025-11

“This paper proposes a feasable mechanism[1]:”

引它说明用汇聚伽马射线制造小黑洞是可行的机制
Physicists drive antihydrogen breakthrough at CERN原评论 ↗
被提交为 story · 2 次