推荐jsweojtj · 2014-08
“I think it would be both amazingly useful and could speed up the iteration rate of science substantially.”
认为把论文各节作为独立单元发表极其有用,能大幅加快科学迭代
提议把论文拆成可单独发表与评审的“积木”
指出计算机领域现行同行评审的缺陷:评审周期长、审稿人负担过重、助长小众话题,进而降低质量、影响力并拖慢创新。论文提出名为 paper bricks 的新评审体系,声称能带来更短的论文、对新想法更好的竞争和更快的创新,且对现有评审体系只需极小改动即可实施。
评论者认为这种模块化发表思路可能大幅加快科学迭代,并称赞这篇论文简短、清晰、好读。
“I think it would be both amazingly useful and could speed up the iteration rate of science substantially.”
“Anyway, recommend reading the paper as it's well written and clear.”
“Very nice, short and readable one, this.”