强烈推荐twic · 2023-01
“There is a classic banger of a paper, "Dispelling the myth of robotic efficiency" [1], which assembles evidence that human space exploration, while expensive, is more cost-effective than robotic.”
强烈推荐,称它汇集证据说明载人探索比机器人更划算
论证载人探索比单靠机器人更能了解太阳系
天文学界普遍认为无人探测器是更高效的行星表面探索者,部分原因是假定机器人探索更便宜,部分原因是预期技术进步会让机器人任务的能力不断提高、尺寸和成本不断下降。作者论证,阿波罗任务的经验、近年的野外类比研究以及机器人探索的发展趋势,都指向相反的结论,并指出若同等条件比较,机器人探索未必更便宜。
评论者称它是「经典之作」,汇集证据说明载人探索虽然昂贵但比机器人更划算,也有人引用其中阿波罗样本论文发表速率的数据。
“There is a classic banger of a paper, "Dispelling the myth of robotic efficiency" [1], which assembles evidence that human space exploration, while expensive, is more cost-effective than robotic.”
“More than that, the rate of publishing continues to outpace them even today, over forty years later.[0][1]”