按年被提到
20132016 · 4 次2026
物理与量子›物理哲学与科学史·arXiv:1312.4057 · physics.hist-ph

Aristotle's Physics: a Physicist's Look

亚里士多德的物理学:物理学家的审视
Carlo Rovelli · 2013

亚里士多德物理学是牛顿力学在流体运动领域的正确近似

开始阅读 ↗PDFalphaXiv 讨论
被推荐 · 9 人首次 2016-07-06 · 最近 2026-08-11
9不同的人
11活跃月份
13讨论串
83被引(OpenAlex)

Rovelli 论证亚里士多德物理学在适当的范围(流体中的运动)内是牛顿物理学的一个正确而反直觉的近似,其技术意义与牛顿理论是爱因斯坦理论的近似相同。他认为这套理论之所以长期流传,不是因为变成了教条,而是因为它是一个有经验基础的好理论,并由此引出对理论之间关系的一些一般性思考。

HN 为什么提它

HN 上的人在讨论科学史和「古人是否愚蠢」时引用它,说明亚里士多德的物理学对他所研究的现象是准确的,是对常见误解的有力反驳。

观点难度 2 / 5约 60 分钟经得起时间
读之前最好知道
1牛顿力学基础
2流体中运动与阻力的基本概念
3亚里士多德物理学的大致观点
4科学理论之间近似关系的概念

HN 书评

推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及
强烈推荐woodandsteel · 2016-07

“according to this astounding article by Carlo Rovelli (yes, that Carlo Rovelli), his physics is accurate for the phenomena he was studying.”

强烈推荐 Rovelli 这篇文章,称亚里士多德物理对其研究的现象是准确的
Has Physics Gotten Something Really Important Really Wrong?原评论 ↗
推荐kwhitefoot · 2016-10

“Also take a look at Carlo Rovelli's monograph: "Aristotle's Physics: a Physicist's Look" at Aristotle's Physics.”

推荐 Rovelli 讲亚里士多德物理学的专著
So You Want to Learn Physics原评论 ↗
推荐foldr · 2017-01

“This is an interesting take on how Aristotle's physics was more correct than he is usually given credit for:”

推荐它:亚里士多德物理学比通常认为的更正确
Why read old philosophy?原评论 ↗
推荐kwhitefoot · 2017-04

“You might want to read Carlo Rovelli's paper Aristotle's Physics.”

建议读 Carlo Rovelli 的这篇论文
Physicists demonstrate new way to violate local causality原评论 ↗
推荐kwhitefoot · 2017-11

“I recommend Carlo Rovelli's essay on Aristotle's Physics:”

推荐 Rovelli 讨论亚里士多德物理学的文章
Science and Tech of the Byzantine Empire原评论 ↗
推荐hackandthink · 2024-12

“You may be interested in:”

推荐它作为背景阅读,对方可能感兴趣
Who can claim Aristotle?原评论 ↗
看全部 11 条 →
引用woodandsteel · 2016-07

“His physics was sound for the particular phenomena he was trying to explain, as this article explains: Aristotle's Physics”

引用此文说明亚里士多德物理对其所解释现象是合理的
There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method原评论 ↗
引用anon_123g987 · 2022-01

“by Carlo Rovelli.”

引用 Rovelli:亚里士多德物理是适用于流体运动的近似
Why Quantum Mechanics?原评论 ↗
引用aeneasmackenzie · 2024-05

“Aristotle said that denser things fall faster than less dense things and even gave a correct expression for their speed given the limits of his mathematics and notation.”

说明亚里士多德在其数学限制下给出了正确的速度表达式
The spy who flunked it: Kurt Gödel's forgotten part in the atom-bomb story原评论 ↗
引用hackandthink · 2024-05

“Carlo Rovelli: "Aristotle's Physics: a Physicist's Look"”

列出 Rovelli 以物理学家身份重新评价亚里士多德物理学的文章
The spy who flunked it: Kurt Gödel's forgotten part in the atom-bomb story原评论 ↗
引用Osmium · 2025-06

“a very reasonable approximation within a certain regime:”

指出亚里士多德的观点在某些范围内是合理近似
Plato got virtually everything wrong (2018)原评论 ↗
被提交为 story · 3 次