“according to this astounding article by Carlo Rovelli (yes, that Carlo Rovelli), his physics is accurate for the phenomena he was studying.”
Aristotle's Physics: a Physicist's Look
亚里士多德物理学是牛顿力学在流体运动领域的正确近似
Rovelli 论证亚里士多德物理学在适当的范围(流体中的运动)内是牛顿物理学的一个正确而反直觉的近似,其技术意义与牛顿理论是爱因斯坦理论的近似相同。他认为这套理论之所以长期流传,不是因为变成了教条,而是因为它是一个有经验基础的好理论,并由此引出对理论之间关系的一些一般性思考。
HN 上的人在讨论科学史和「古人是否愚蠢」时引用它,说明亚里士多德的物理学对他所研究的现象是准确的,是对常见误解的有力反驳。
HN 书评
推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及“Also take a look at Carlo Rovelli's monograph: "Aristotle's Physics: a Physicist's Look" at Aristotle's Physics.”
“This is an interesting take on how Aristotle's physics was more correct than he is usually given credit for:”
“You might want to read Carlo Rovelli's paper Aristotle's Physics.”
“I recommend Carlo Rovelli's essay on Aristotle's Physics:”
“You may be interested in:”
看全部 11 条 →
“His physics was sound for the particular phenomena he was trying to explain, as this article explains: Aristotle's Physics”
“by Carlo Rovelli.”
“Aristotle said that denser things fall faster than less dense things and even gave a correct expression for their speed given the limits of his mathematics and notation.”
“Carlo Rovelli: "Aristotle's Physics: a Physicist's Look"”
“a very reasonable approximation within a certain regime:”
- Aristotle’s Physics: A Physicist’s Look ↗kwhitefoot · 2016-07-13 · 3 分
- Aristotle’s Physics: A Physicist’s Look (2014) ↗Tomte · 2022-09-10 · 1 分
- Aristotle's Physics: A Physicist's Look ↗lordleft · 2026-08-11 · 1 分