引用qwtel · 2018-03
“this has been done by cirillo and taleb [1], and the results are sobering: there is no evidence for a drop in violence.”
引用 Cirillo 和 Taleb 的结果:没有证据显示暴力在下降
用极值理论分析两千年战争数据,质疑长期和平论
论文考察过去 2000 年暴力冲突的统计图景,提出处理历史数据不完整、不可靠的技术。作者引入新方法,把极值理论应用到有遥远但有限上界的厚尾变量上:通过定义对应的无界对偶分布(战争伤亡受世界人口限制),在对偶分布上推导尾部性质。结果显示战争伤亡的真实均值远大于样本均值,即朴素观察严重低估了冲突的尾部风险;尾部事件的到达间隔也没有可断言的趋势,这些结果都与暴力随时间下降的长期和平论相悖。
HN 上的人引用它说明在厚尾统计下没有证据表明暴力在下降,也把它作为 Taleb 在正规期刊上发表的偏重数学的文章,用来说明厚尾风险被低估。
“this has been done by cirillo and taleb [1], and the results are sobering: there is no evidence for a drop in violence.”
“The consequences can be seen in systemic financial failures; in ineffective pandemic responses; and in much of social science. See for example:”
“here are a few of his papers published in respectable journals that have non negligible math content”