批评Vecr · 2024-10
“As far as I can tell they're still making impossible assumptions, because certain Bayesian problems can't be calculated under a certain amount of energy”
用贝叶斯更新把测量信息纳入,推广热力学第二定律
推导出热力学第二定律的一个推广,用贝叶斯更新显式纳入对系统的测量效应,化解了“统计系统熵可能向下涨落”与“随机演化系统的知识随时间退化”之间的张力。其形式为交叉熵变化加上广义热流期望非负,还给出了下界为非负数的细化版本和贝叶斯版 Jarzynski 等式,并用简单解析与数值例子演示。
评论者用它说明 KL 散度可以用来推广远离平衡系统的第二定律,也有人质疑其假设忽略了贝叶斯计算的能量下限。
“As far as I can tell they're still making impossible assumptions, because certain Bayesian problems can't be calculated under a certain amount of energy”
“KL divergence has also been used to generalize the second law of thermodynamics for systems far from equilibrium:”