按年被提到
20152016 · 3 次2026
编程语言与编译器›类型系统与函数式语言·arXiv:1512.01895 · cs.PL

Modular implicits

模块化隐式参数
Leo White, Frédéric Bour, Jeremy Yallop · 2015

为 OCaml 加入类型驱动的隐式模块参数,实现特设多态

开始阅读 ↗PDFalphaXiv 讨论
被推荐 · 13 人首次 2015-12-12 · 最近 2025-08-13
13不同的人
12活跃月份
12讨论串
27被引(OpenAlex)

论文提出 modular implicits,一种受 Scala implicits 和模块化 type class 启发的 OCaml 语言扩展,用于特设多态(ad-hoc polymorphism)。它基于类型驱动的隐式模块参数,可直接展开为 OCaml 的一等 functor,因此天然支持继承、实例约束、constructor class 和 associated types 等其他语言中的特性。

HN 为什么提它

HN 上的人把它当作在 ML 模块的灵活性和 type class 的便利重载之间取得务实平衡的方案,并称论文本身好读、不空谈理论。

方法难度 4 / 5约 80 分钟经得起时间
读之前最好知道
1OCaml 的模块系统与 functor
2类型类(type class)与特设多态(ad-hoc polymorphism)
3Hindley-Milner 类型推断
4Scala implicits 的基本概念

HN 书评

推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及
推荐ubertaco · 2016-04

“there's a paper on it that actually is readable instead of just all whitepapery and overly-theoretical”

推荐这篇论文,比偏理论的论文好读得多
An OCaml manifesto – Problems and what's needed for widespread adoption原评论 ↗
推荐krat0sprakhar · 2016-04

“if anyone's keen on reading the paper behind modular implicits in OCaml, its a fun read”

推荐想了解 OCaml modular implicits 的人读这篇,读起来有趣
OCaml 4.03.0 released (including flambda)原评论 ↗
推荐jdreaver · 2018-06

“This is really exciting because modular implicits represent a pragmatic balance between the flexibility of ML modules and the convenient overloading of type classes.”

认为 modular implicits 在 ML modules 的灵活与 type classes 的便利之间取得务实平衡
Gluon – A static, type-inferred and embeddable language written in Rust原评论 ↗
推荐bjz_ · 2018-08

“One nice solution is modular implicits/instance arguments [1][2].”

推荐 modular implicits 作为一个不错的方案
Small Assets without the Headache in Elm 0.19原评论 ↗
推荐Shoop · 2021-01

“check out this lovely paper about Modular Implicits in OCaml [1]. The paper is quite accessible if you have some FP background.”

推荐这篇 OCaml modular implicits 论文,有 FP 基础就很易读
Exotic List Monads原评论 ↗
推荐sgeisenh · 2021-12

“I hadn't seen a great type-safe way to support ad hoc polymorphism until I read about [modular implicits][1] in OCaml.”

读到 modular implicits 才见到类型安全的 ad hoc polymorphism 好办法
One Reason Typeclasses Are Useful原评论 ↗
看全部 12 条 →
引用pauldirac137 · 2016-03

“Modular implicits are described here: Modular implicits.”

引用它说明 modular implicits 如何描述,让 OCaml 模块像 type classes 一样用
An OCaml manifesto – Problems and what's needed for widespread adoption原评论 ↗
引用lptk · 2018-04

“modular implicits aim to make this better (see Modular implicits)”

指出 modular implicits 想改善 ML 模块冗长笨重的问题
Towards Scala 3原评论 ↗
引用tutanchamun · 2019-09

“As a layman I would describe them as implicits like in current Scala [0] but better (easier to reason about).”

把它类比为更好理解的 Scala implicits
A look back on OCaml since 2011原评论 ↗
引用lpage · 2021-08

“There's more to it than that [7].”

指出 modular implicits 的内容不止前文所说,附上论文
Functional Programming in OCaml原评论 ↗
引用nequo · 2024-07

“The original paper was published in 2014.”

指出 modular implicits 的原始论文发表于 2014 年
Node.js adds experimental support for TypeScript原评论 ↗
引用nukifw · 2025-08

“No typeclasses, yes, for the moment but the first step of Modular implicits is under review”

指出 OCaml 暂时没有 typeclasses,但这篇的第一步正在评审
OCaml as my primary language原评论 ↗
被提交为 story · 1 次