按年被提到
20162023 · 8 次2026
物理与量子›引力与基础物理·arXiv:1609.01421 · math-ph

Struggles with the Continuum

与连续统的纠缠
John C. Baez · 2016

综述把时空视为连续统给数学物理带来的奇点与发散

开始阅读 ↗PDFalphaXiv 讨论
被推荐 · 9 人首次 2016-09-07 · 最近 2025-11-26
9不同的人
15活跃月份
18讨论串
1被引(OpenAlex)

Baez 指出,我们假定时空是连续统,这在数学物理中引出许多难题:从牛顿引力、经典电动力学到量子电动力学和标准模型,奇点和发散积分都威胁着这些理论。在广义相对论中,奇点又与该理论最引人注目的成功预测密切相关。文章综述了这些问题以及人们为处理它们所做的大量工作。

HN 为什么提它

HN 上的人在讨论物理是否应该摆脱连续性、无穷与发散时反复引用它,作为物理中奇点与无穷问题的易读概览,不少人借它论证对连续形式体系的怀疑。

综述难度 3 / 5约 150 分钟经得起时间
读之前最好知道
1经典力学与电动力学
2广义相对论的基本概念
3量子场论与重整化(renormalization)的大意
4微积分与连续统的基本概念

HN 书评

推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及
推荐j2kun · 2017-01

“Try this physics paper[1] explaining how pretty much every model we have of physics is broken in fundamental ways.”

推荐它,称其解释了物理学几乎所有模型都存在根本缺陷
What If Time Really Exists? (2008)原评论 ↗
推荐mikhailfranco · 2017-04

“For the parallel historical development of 'the continuum' in physics, I recommend this readable survey:”

推荐这篇易读的综述,了解物理中连续统的平行发展史
How real are real numbers? (2004)原评论 ↗
推荐raattgift · 2021-07

“and the concluding §6 is pithy”

称结尾第 6 节言简意赅
A proof P = NP was accidentally published in TOCT原评论 ↗
推荐throwaway81523 · 2022-11

“Here's a cool expository article about blow-ups in classical mechanics and elsewhere:”

推荐一篇有趣的科普文章,讲经典力学等中的 blow-up
Computer proof ‘blows up’ centuries-old fluid equations原评论 ↗
推荐naasking · 2023-12

“Baez has a good overview of these kinds of problems”

称 Baez 对这类问题有很好的概述
Roy Kerr: Do Black Holes Have Singularities?原评论 ↗
引用raattgift · 2016-09

“Just today Baez just helped you out a bit: Struggles with the Continuum”

指出 Baez 今天刚好写了相关内容可参考
Paranoid Android: The Divine Madness of Philip K Dick原评论 ↗
看全部 15 条 →
引用macrolocal · 2021-09

“As an aside, this idea that reality is "geometrical" leads to all kinds of fascinating paradoxes[1].”

顺带指出现实是“几何的”这一想法会引出许多悖论
How to fit any dataset with a single parameter原评论 ↗
引用naasking · 2023-01

“Continuous quantities in physics are being systematically removed because they almost inevitably introduce absurdities [1].”

引用它说明物理中的连续量几乎必然带来荒谬,正被系统性剔除
How Organisms Come to Know the World: Fundamental Limits on AGI原评论 ↗
引用naasking · 2023-02

“IMO, baking continuity and uncountable infinities is what's responsible for many of the difficulties we've had, and various forms of discretization have resolved these issues in the past [2].”

认为连续性和不可数无穷是许多困难的根源,离散化曾解决过这些问题
Norton's Dome原评论 ↗
引用naasking · 2023-02

“I've become very suspicious of continuous formalisms period:”

称自己对连续形式体系非常怀疑
Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities原评论 ↗
引用naasking · 2023-02

“A more fringe reason, but one I think will resolve some of those issues is a growing skepticism of continuity [1], even for classical mechanics”

指出对连续性的怀疑日益增长,即使在经典力学中
Towards quantum computers that are robust to errors原评论 ↗
引用naasking · 2023-07

“Physics has repeatedly had to tame infinities by elaborate tricks, or by eliminating them entirely [1].”

引用它说明物理学一再靠精巧技巧或彻底消除来驯服无穷
The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy原评论 ↗
引用naasking · 2023-07

“Struggles with the Continuum, Struggles with the Continuum”

引用它说明物理中的发散与无穷,如紫外灾难
The Physicist Who’s Challenging the Quantum Orthodoxy原评论 ↗
引用naasking · 2024-03

“our continuous formalisms are at the very heart of some core problems in physics [1]”

认为连续形式体系正是物理学一些核心问题的根源
Large Language Models Are Neurosymbolic Reasoners原评论 ↗
引用naasking · 2025-11

“I think Baez's paper, Struggles with the Continuum, shows a lot of past difficulties we've had that resulted from this:”

认为 Baez 这篇展示了由此造成的许多过往困难
A new bridge links the math of infinity to computer science原评论 ↗
被提交为 story · 4 次