推荐ISL · 2020-07
“One should not miss Figure 1 of the arXiv preprint, which is, alas, absent from the final PRL.”
推荐别错过 arXiv 预印本的图 1,正式发表版里已删去
提出第九行星可能是被太阳系俘获的原初黑洞
论文指出,海外天体的异常轨道和 OGLE 微透镜事件的过量,可能由一类质量为数倍地球的新天体同时解释,并假设它们是原初黑洞。作者论证太阳系俘获这样一个黑洞的概率与俘获自由漂浮行星相当,其观测约束与普通第九行星不同,并可通过其暗物质微晕的湮灭信号来检验。
HN 上提到它多半是出于趣味:有人推荐 arXiv 版本里按比例绘制的 Figure 1,也有人批评它不是从观测出发自然得出黑洞的结论。
“One should not miss Figure 1 of the arXiv preprint, which is, alas, absent from the final PRL.”
“It doesn't start from observations and arrive at the PBH in any natural way.”
“One speculative possibility is that we could find a continuous gamma annihilation signal from its dark matter halo,”
“This paper exploring the idea has as Fig 1. a to-scale illustration of a 5-Earth-mass primordial black hole:”
“which leads to my favourite "actual size" caption on a diagram, page 5:”