“I really don't like how GitHub has turned into a social network of sorts. The gamified elements are encouraging people to work for free and MS probably knows this. GitHub should just be a place to host and build code, not to flex your follower or star count. Some examples of gamified elements I find quite toxic: * Achievements on profiles * Highlights o…”
How Gamification Affects Software Developers: Cautionary Evidence from a Natural Experiment on GitHub
GitHub 移除连续提交计数后,开发者行为发生了显著变化
论文考察 GitHub 在未事先通知的情况下,把用户主页上的每日活动连续天数计数器移除后,开发者行为的变化。长期连续提交被放弃且变少,周末活动减少,每天只做一次贡献的日子变少,社交网络里连续提交行为的同步性也下降,说明游戏化是强有力的社会影响渠道。在公开挑战“连续 100 天提交”的开发者中,也有人在公开计数器消失后放弃了目标;作者提醒游戏化可能把开发者行为引向意外且不想要的方向。
输入没有提供评论摘录,只能确认它在 HN 上被三位不同的人在不同月份提到过,具体原因无从判断。
HN 书评
没有评论直接链到它;下面是它被提交的讨论串里回复最多的评论(不计入统计)“If someone told me they're striving to achieve 100 days in a row of contributing, my first thoughts would be "egocentrism" and "dishonesty". Helping isn't about you helping. And if you're aiming for 100 days in a row, I'm pretty sure you're pushing changes you could've pushed during the week on Saturday and Sunday to keep up the streak. Somebody could've …”
“Martin from GitHub here. I think we’d consider this very much ‘by design’ in removing the streak counter so I’m glad it had the desired affect. Coding 100 days straight with no breaks isn’t good for anyone.”
- How Gamification Affects Software Developers, a Thesis on GitHub Streaks [pdf] ↗guessmyname · 2020-11-14 · 2 分
- Gamification Affects Software Developers: Cautionary Evidence from GitHub ↗oss_fan · 2022-02-18 · 2 分
- Gamification affects software developers: Cautionary evidence from GitHub ↗edward · 2022-10-23 · 264 分