批评Strilanc · 2021-10
“It's actually from last year, and other groups have done better experiments since then”
用 13 个囚禁离子量子比特实验演示 Bacon-Shor 逻辑比特容错操作
论文用 13 个囚禁离子量子比特,实验演示 Bacon-Shor 逻辑量子比特的容错制备、测量、旋转与稳定子测量。与非容错协议相比,容错协议在噪声下显著降低了逻辑原语的错误率;纠错后平均态制备与测量错误为 0.6%,Clifford 门错误为 0.3%,并制备出保真度超过蒸馏阈值的魔术态,展示了通用容错操作所需的全部关键单比特要素。作者指出,借助更好的两比特门和中间测量,可实现稳定的逻辑比特。
HN 评论者把它作为早期用 13 个物理量子比特演示容错量子纠错测量的实验例子,也有人指出它其实是上一年的工作,此后别的团队已有更好的实验。
“It's actually from last year, and other groups have done better experiments since then”
“One of the first example is the experiment of Egan et al where they demonstrated a fault-tolerant QEC measurement using 13 physical qubits.”