“[A study](https://arxiv.org/abs/2010.09761) posted 2020-10-19 challenges the claim that phosphine was detected in Venus's atmosphere. [The original claim](https://www.nature.com/articles/s41550-020-1174-4), posted 2020-10-14.”
Re-analysis of the 267-GHz ALMA observations of Venus: No statistically significant detection of phosphine
Context: ALMA observations of Venus at 267 GHz have been presented in the literature that show the apparent presence of phosphine (PH3) in its atmosphere. Phosphine has currently no evident production routes on the planet's surface or in its atmosphere. Aims: The aim of this work is to assess the statistical reliability of the line detection by independent re-analysis of the ALMA data. Methods: The ALMA data were reduced as in the published study, following the provided scripts. First the spectral analysis presented in the study was reproduced and assessed. Subsequently, the spectrum was statistically evaluated, including its dependence on selected ALMA baselines. Results: We find that the 12th-order polynomial fit to the spectral passband utilised in the published study leads to spurious results. Following their recipe, five other >10 sigma lines can be produced in absorption or emission within 60 km/s from the PH3 1-0 transition frequency by suppressing the surrounding noise. Our independent analysis shows a feature near the PH3 frequency at a ~2 sigma level, below the common threshold for statistical significance. Since the spectral data have a non-Gaussian distribution, we consider a feature at such level as statistically unreliable that cannot be linked to a false positive probability. Conclusions: We find that the published 267-GHz ALMA data provide no statistical evidence for phosphine in the atmosphere of Venus.
候选层:至少 2 个不同的人、在 2 个不同月份提到过,还没到主书架的 3 人 3 个月。没有做立场标注,所以只写“被提及”。
HN 书评
推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及“I was more convinced that the original paper may have problems by https://arxiv.org/abs/2010.09761 From that preprint: > We find that the 12th-order polynomial fit to the spectral passband utilised in the published study leads to spurious results. Using a 12th-order polynomial fit is very suspicious? And I think that it is very interesting to see Figure…”
“The idea is that you want to split your data as a sum of three parts: (a) a smooth function that is not interesting (b) noise (c) a big unexpected peak in an interesting part There is a nice preprint posted a few days ago: https://arxiv.org/abs/2010.09761 https://arxiv.org/abs/2010.09761.pdf They reanalyze the data than in the phosphine paper. --- …”
- Re-analysis of ALMA observations of Venus: No significant detection of phosphine ↗pinewurst · 2020-10-21 · 5 分
- Re-analysis: No statistically significant detection of phosphine on Venus ↗perihelions · 2020-10-21 · 4 分
- No statistically significant detection of phosphine on Venus ↗occamschainsaw · 2020-10-22 · 2 分