“There was some research a few years ago [2] into just how widespread this issue was in scientific publishing.”
Tortured phrases: A dubious writing style emerging in science. Evidence of critical issues affecting established journals
提出“扭曲短语”概念,揭露期刊中疑似机器改写的文本
论文提出“扭曲短语”概念,即用怪异说法替换既定术语,如把 artificial intelligence 写成 counterfeit consciousness。作者以一家期刊为例,用检测器发现其摘要被标为“合成”的比例明显偏高,并指出编辑时间线异常、引用不存在的文献和图片未声明复用等问题,认为部分作者用文本改写工具凑稿,呼吁调查。
评论者引用它说明这些怪异短语多来自 SpinBot 之类用同义词替换来躲避查重的文本改写工具,用来讨论科学出版中的低质量文本。
HN 书评
推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及“Per the original paper [1], the tortured phrases observed in these papers can be reproduced by running text through an online tool”
“Some more examples of these tortured phrases: Tortured phrases”
“Tortured phrases found that many of the commonly observed phrases were characteristic of an online text-spinning tool.”
“Tortured phrases found that a lot of the outputs were characteristic of an online tool called SpinBot.”
“believed to be caused by plagiarism evasion tools that change random words to applicable synonyms.”
- A dubious writing style emerging in science ↗doener · 2021-08-11 · 110 分