推荐finned · 2023-09
“they wrote a detailed paper on this topic, which is worth reading in full:”
推荐全文细读,这篇论文详细讨论了对儿童安全扫描的反对意见能否解决
英国官员剖析儿童安全与加密的两难,提出“伤害原型”
端到端加密破坏了平台目前使用的许多儿童性侵防范措施,由此引出儿童安全与用户隐私安全似乎二选一的争论,而这场争论多集中在用客户端扫描检测已知违法图像的传播者上。论文指出真实问题远比这复杂,提出一套“伤害原型”(harm archetypes)来按技术特征对危害分类,并梳理平台与执法机构现有的处理流程。文中还高层次地探讨了各种可能的技术手段及其利弊,并以一个假想服务为例,说明如何组合这些手段,在保护用户隐私和安全的同时保护儿童并支持执法。
评论者认为这篇详细的论文值得通读,并称它由英国官员撰写,初衷是促成更充分、更知情的辩论,探讨儿童安全扫描方面的反对意见能否化解。
“they wrote a detailed paper on this topic, which is worth reading in full:”
“With a stated aim to "to educate and inform in order to allow a more detailed and informed debate to happen" and appears a genuine in that goal.”