“This paper from 2017 showed QUIC performance was poor: QUIC is not Quick Enough over Fast Internet”
QUIC is not Quick Enough over Fast Internet
高速网络下 QUIC/HTTP3 吞吐比 TCP/HTTP2 最多低 45.2%
论文系统测量 QUIC 在高速网络上的表现:在高速互联网上,UDP+QUIC+HTTP/3 的数据速率比 TCP+TLS+HTTP/2 最多低 45.2%,带宽越高差距越大,在轻量客户端和多种主流浏览器、桌面与移动端、有线与蜂窝网络上都能观察到。作者通过抓包与内核、用户态剖析,把根因定位到接收端处理开销过高,尤其是过多的数据包和 QUIC 的用户态 ACK,并给出缓解建议。
评论者用它的数字(吞吐最多降 45.2%、视频码率最多降 9.8%)说明 QUIC 在高速大带宽链路上扩展性不佳,瓶颈在 UDP 协议栈和接收端开销。
HN 书评
推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及“Don't have access to the published version but draft at QUIC is not Quick Enough over Fast Internet mentions ping RTT at 0.23ms.”
“We find that over fast Internet, the UDP+QUIC+HTTP/3 stack suffers a data rate reduction of up to 45.2% compared to the TCP+TLS+HTTP/2 counterpart.”
“This is a big part of why QUIC really struggles to scale well for fat pipes [1]”
“The linked paper claims seeing up to a 9.8% video bitrate reduction from HTTP/2 (TCP) to HTTP/3 (QUIC).”
- QUIC is not quick enough over fast internet ↗carlos-menezes · 2024-10-19 · 313 分