批评thisislife2 · 2026-02
“I think this research is being used for propaganda marketing to push for MV3 adoption”
实验显示MV3下主流广告拦截器效果没有显著下降
谷歌把 Chrome 扩展从 MV2 升级到 MV3,把强大的 WebRequest API 换成限制更多的 DeclarativeNetRequest API,引发广告拦截器可能变弱的担忧。作者在多组带广告网站样本上做浏览器实验,对比四款常用广告拦截器的 MV3 与 MV2 版本,发现 MV3 版本在拦截广告和反追踪效果上没有统计显著的下降,某些情况下追踪器拦截甚至略有改善。作者据此认为主流拦截器基本适应了 MV3,但承认仍有不确定性。
HN 评论者引它说明 MV3 版 uBO Lite 对大多数用户至少和 MV2 版一样好用,也有人批评这项研究被用来为推广 MV3 做宣传。
“I think this research is being used for propaganda marketing to push for MV3 adoption”
“However, this paper[1] suggests that uBO Lite (MV3) which is still supported in the latest Chrome/chromium browsers, works at least as well for almost all users as the original (MV2) uBO”
“That's not me saying that, here is a paper from researchers at Goethe University Frankfurt who tested it:”