引用samusiam · 2026-02
“It completely depends on how you use it. See, for example, this study”
拿它说明 AI 的影响完全取决于怎么用
随机实验:借助 AI 学新编程库,会削弱理解与调试能力
论文用随机实验研究开发者在有无 AI 辅助下学习一个新的异步编程库,发现使用 AI 会削弱概念理解、读代码和调试能力,平均也没有带来显著的效率提升。完全交给 AI 写代码的参与者效率略有提高,但学得更差;作者归纳出六种 AI 交互模式,其中三种保持认知参与,即使有 AI 帮助也能保住学习效果。
HN 评论者在讨论“用 AI 会不会妨碍学习”时引用这项 Anthropic 研究,说明效果取决于使用方式,例如只用来澄清概念反而有益。
“It completely depends on how you use it. See, for example, this study”
“Anthropic's study, same as above except supplementary use (like clarifying concepts) can actually be beneficial.”
“How AI Impacts Skill Formation (from Anthropic)”
“That's this study here: How AI Impacts Skill Formation”
“I found inspiration for the tool from reading a research paper on skill formation from Anthropic”