“If you haven't read it already I highly recommend Thurston's essay”
On proof and progress in mathematics
数学的进步不只靠形式证明,更在于人与人之间的理解
Thurston 回应 Jaffe 与 Quinn 的文章,讨论形式化证明无法涵盖的数学进步形式,并以他在叶状结构理论、3-流形几何化和动力系统上的工作为例。核心观点是:数学的目标是推进人类的理解,证明新定理只是其中的一部分。
HN 上的人反复拿它说明数学的本质是理解而非单纯验证,常在讨论形式化证明、计算机验证和数学研究文化时推荐,并称其无需数学基础也值得一读。
HN 书评
推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及“which I also highly recommend, I especially like Thurston's article”
“It a gem that could only have been written by a lovely man.”
“I highly recommend Bill Thurston's gem of an article On proof and progress in mathematics”
“Highly recommend irrespective of how involved you are with mathematics.”
“I highly recommend Bill Thurston”
看全部 20 条 →
“please have a look at William Thurston's paper "On Proofs and Progress in Mathematics" here--just great: On proof and progress in mathematics”
“there is a link to a paper[1] by Thurston that is well worth your time.”
“Gives a good amount of insight into how academia works for mathematics, and gives a good contrast with how CS works.”
“I really like Bill Thurston's perspective, from the famous essay "On proof and progress in mathematics", which is that proving new theorems is only a small part of the project of mathematics.”
“If you haven't already, take a look at Bill Thurston's paper”
“Also, Bill Thurston's beautiful "On Proof and Progress in Mathematics" [1] contains several ways to understand the derivative”
“You might find Thurston's essay "On Proof and Progress in Mathematics" (arXiv link: [2]) interesting too.”
“Famed mathematician William Thurston has a good response here”
“See this well known article by the illustrious Bill Thurston (RIP):”
“On Proof and Progress in Mathematics[1][2] is a great essay by a Field's medalist.”
“a great read for young people interested in mathematics and influenced me while in undergrad deciding to persue a PhD in math”
“William Thurston's very insightful "On Proof and Progress in Mathematics":”
“Here's a good essay by Thurston "Proof and Progress in mathematics". On proof and progress in mathematics”
“definition for a derivative looks incorrect under the section”