按年被提到
19942026 · 9 次2026
数学、逻辑与理论›数学哲学与数学文化·arXiv:math/9404236 · math.HO

On proof and progress in mathematics

论数学中的证明与进步
William P. Thurston · 1994

数学的进步不只靠形式证明,更在于人与人之间的理解

开始阅读 ↗PDFalphaXiv 讨论
被推荐 · 39 人首次 2009-11-10 · 最近 2026-10-23发表于 Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society
39不同的人
29活跃月份
41讨论串
655被引(OpenAlex)

Thurston 回应 Jaffe 与 Quinn 的文章,讨论形式化证明无法涵盖的数学进步形式,并以他在叶状结构理论、3-流形几何化和动力系统上的工作为例。核心观点是:数学的目标是推进人类的理解,证明新定理只是其中的一部分。

HN 为什么提它

HN 上的人反复拿它说明数学的本质是理解而非单纯验证,常在讨论形式化证明、计算机验证和数学研究文化时推荐,并称其无需数学基础也值得一读。

观点难度 2 / 5约 40 分钟经得起时间
读之前最好知道
1基本的数学证明概念
2对数学研究方式的粗略了解
3几何与拓扑(geometry and topology)常识(可选)

HN 书评

推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及
强烈推荐mreid · 2009-12

“If you haven't read it already I highly recommend Thurston's essay”

强烈推荐还没读过的人读 Thurston 这篇文章
What is math?原评论 ↗
强烈推荐tokenadult · 2012-08

“which I also highly recommend, I especially like Thurston's article”

强烈推荐,尤其喜欢 Thurston 这篇文章
Bill Thurston has died原评论 ↗
强烈推荐gruseom · 2012-08

“It a gem that could only have been written by a lovely man.”

称它是只有好人才写得出的珍宝,强烈推荐
Bill Thurston has died原评论 ↗
强烈推荐ssivark · 2020-06

“I highly recommend Bill Thurston's gem of an article On proof and progress in mathematics”

强烈推荐这篇佳作,无需形式数学即可读
In Mathematics, It Often Takes a Good Map to Find Answers原评论 ↗
强烈推荐19f191ty · 2020-06

“Highly recommend irrespective of how involved you are with mathematics.”

强烈推荐,不论与数学关系深浅
Bill Thurston's answer to “What's a mathematician to do?” (2010)原评论 ↗
强烈推荐physidev · 2025-08

“I highly recommend Bill Thurston”

强烈推荐 Bill Thurston 谈数学家如何推进证明与理解
Cognitive load is what matters原评论 ↗
看全部 20 条 →
推荐proofschool · 2013-08

“please have a look at William Thurston's paper "On Proofs and Progress in Mathematics" here--just great: On proof and progress in mathematics”

推荐 Thurston 这篇论文,称非常棒
Proof School原评论 ↗
推荐bkcooper · 2014-09

“there is a link to a paper[1] by Thurston that is well worth your time.”

推荐 Thurston 这篇论文,值得花时间读
What's a Mathematician to do?原评论 ↗
推荐cmrx64 · 2014-11

“Gives a good amount of insight into how academia works for mathematics, and gives a good contrast with how CS works.”

推荐它让人了解数学学界如何运作,并与计算机科学形成对比
Ask HN: What are your favorite scholarly papers? Why?原评论 ↗
推荐davmre · 2015-03

“I really like Bill Thurston's perspective, from the famous essay "On proof and progress in mathematics", which is that proving new theorems is only a small part of the project of mathematics.”

推荐 Thurston 的观点:证明新定理只是数学事业的一小部分
Terence Tao: the Mozart of maths原评论 ↗
推荐erje · 2015-07

“If you haven't already, take a look at Bill Thurston's paper”

建议还没读的人看看 Thurston 这篇论文
Will Our Understanding of Math Deteriorate Over Time?原评论 ↗
推荐mrkgnao · 2016-05

“Also, Bill Thurston's beautiful "On Proof and Progress in Mathematics" [1] contains several ways to understand the derivative”

推荐这篇漂亮的文章,其中有几种理解导数的方式
Functional Programming, Abstraction, and Names原评论 ↗
推荐mrkgnao · 2017-03

“You might find Thurston's essay "On Proof and Progress in Mathematics" (arXiv link: [2]) interesting too.”

补充推荐 Thurston 这篇文章,认为也很有意思
The Mathematics Autodidact’s Aid (2005) [pdf]原评论 ↗
推荐jasonhong · 2020-08

“Famed mathematician William Thurston has a good response here”

推荐 Thurston 的回应:理解的重要性超出计算机验证的证明
Computer Search Settles 90-Year-Old Math Problem原评论 ↗
推荐throwaway81523 · 2021-07

“See this well known article by the illustrious Bill Thurston (RIP):”

推荐 Thurston 这篇名文:证明为了理解而非单纯验证
The Dawn of Formalized Mathematics原评论 ↗
推荐BeetleB · 2023-06

“On Proof and Progress in Mathematics[1][2] is a great essay by a Field's medalist.”

推荐这篇菲尔兹奖得主的好文章
The Matrix Cookbook [pdf]原评论 ↗
推荐joewferrara · 2023-07

“a great read for young people interested in mathematics and influenced me while in undergrad deciding to persue a PhD in math”

推荐年轻人读,称它影响自己在本科时决定攻读数学博士
It's not mathematics that you need to contribute to (2010)原评论 ↗
推荐svat · 2023-11

“William Thurston's very insightful "On Proof and Progress in Mathematics":”

推荐 Thurston 这篇极具洞见的文章
Ninth Dedekind number found by two independent groups原评论 ↗
推荐enugu · 2024-12

“Here's a good essay by Thurston "Proof and Progress in mathematics". On proof and progress in mathematics”

推荐 Thurston 这篇好文,谈数学进步以及跨过吓人的术语
Fermat's Last Theorem – how it’s going原评论 ↗
批评noblethrasher · 2012-08

“definition for a derivative looks incorrect under the section”

Bill Thurston has died原评论 ↗