引用duaneb · 2012-03
“Other people, most notably and substantially Max Tegmark, disagree[1], arguing,”
指出 Tegmark 不同意,并以退相干时间尺度反驳 Penrose 的大脑量子观点
计算神经退相干速率,论证大脑是经典而非量子系统
论文计算神经系统的退相干速率,发现神经元放电和微管中扭结状极化激发的退相干时间尺度约为 10^-13 到 10^-20 秒,远短于相关动力学时间尺度(约 0.001 到 0.1 秒)。据此认为与认知相关的大脑自由度应视为经典系统,现有的经典神经网络模拟路线并无根本问题,这与 Penrose 等人主张大脑是量子计算机、量子相干与意识有本质联系的观点相左。
HN 上的人在讨论大脑是否依赖量子效应、意识是否需要量子计算时,用它作为反驳 Penrose 一派的主要论据。
“Other people, most notably and substantially Max Tegmark, disagree[1], arguing,”
“According to Max Tegmark's calculations, the importance of quantum mechanical effects on brain processes is negligible:”
“but this paper The importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes shows human brain is more classical than quantum.”
“have generally concluded the answer is no:”
“This paper by Tegmark argues it doesn't - The importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes”