“I thought it was at least as interesting as Robert Axelrod's simulation of successful strategies in the iterated prisoner's dilemma.”
按年被提到
20092010 · 4 次2026
The Peter Principle Revisited: A Computational Study
重访彼得原理:一项计算研究
Alessandro Pluchino, Andrea Rapisarda, Cesare Garofalo · 2009
仿真显示彼得原理成立,随机晋升反而最有效
被推荐 · 13 人首次 2009-07-06 · 最近 2025-01-28
13不同的人
13活跃月份
14讨论串
78被引(OpenAlex)
彼得原理认为组织中的成员会一路晋升到自己最不称职的层级。作者用基于智能体的仿真表明,只要晋升奖励最优秀的成员、且新岗位上的表现与原岗位的能力无关,彼得原理就不可避免,并显著降低组织的整体效率。在类博弈论的框架下比较多种晋升策略,结果违反直觉:避免该效应的最佳办法是每次随机晋升,或随机晋升最好与最差的成员。
HN 为什么提它
评论者引用它说明「随机晋升比按绩效晋升更有效」的仿真结果(论文获得了搞笑诺贝尔奖),常带着调侃讨论组织管理,也有人认为它的洞察不输 Axelrod 的囚徒困境仿真。
实证研究难度 2 / 5约 25 分钟经得起时间
读之前最好知道
1彼得原理与组织层级
2基于智能体的建模(agent-based modeling)
3博弈论基础
4基础统计
HN 书评
推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及推荐plint · 2022-12
认为它至少和 Axelrod 的囚徒困境模拟一样有趣
引用gjm11 · 2009-07
“Yes, I read the paper.”
说自己读过这篇论文,彼得原理的计算模拟
引用kenjackson · 2010-11
“This also reminds me of a paper I had submitted in the past. Randomly promoting people is more effective than using merit:”
想起自己提交的论文:随机晋升比按能力晋升更有效
引用mikeryan · 2011-04
“This fits nicely with the study which shows that organizations are more efficient if people are promoted at random;-)”
说这与“随机晋升让组织更高效”的研究吻合
引用GuB-42 · 2017-11
“There is even a igNobel winning publication suggesting that it might be more efficient to promote people at random... The Peter Principle Revisited”
提到有搞笑诺贝尔奖论文认为随机晋升可能更高效
被提交为 story · 9 次
- The Peter Principle Revisited: A Computational Study ↗sarosh · 2010-02-12 · 5 分
- The Peter Principle Revisited: A Computational Study(IgNobel 2010) ↗samuel · 2010-10-02 · 2 分
- Randomly Promoting People is More Efficient Than Using Merit ↗kenjackson · 2010-10-08 · 4 分
- The Peter Principle Revisited: A Computational Study [pdf] ↗signa11 · 2011-02-28 · 13 分
- The Peter Principle ↗x-sam · 2013-07-14 · 7 分
- Organizations would become more efficient randomly promoting employees ↗jalcazar · 2016-09-13 · 1 分