“I would highly recommend people here to take a look at: Talent vs Luck”
Talent vs Luck: the role of randomness in success and failure
仿真显示最成功的人往往只是运气最好
用一个简单的基于主体的模型解释:才能近似服从正态分布,而财富服从幂律,这种落差背后的隐藏因素是随机性。模型结果显示,成功需要一定才能,但最有才能的人几乎从不攀上最高峰,常被运气更好的普通人超过;文章还据此比较了几种科研经费分配策略。
它常被用来论证成功很大程度上靠运气和网络效应而非单纯才能,但也有评论者批评模型参数缺乏论证、只是把作者的世界观写成模型。
学习路径
读这篇之前,按顺序读书架上的 5 篇 · 参考文献来自 OpenAlex,顺序和要点由 Claude Code 排出这条路径涵盖幂律与财富分布、经济物理模型,以及同一作者关于随机性的前期仿真,再读运气与才能的模拟。
- 1
说明财富等量遵循幂律的经验背景,对应目标论文中才能服从高斯分布而财富服从幂律的对比。
读抓帕累托分布与财富分布的部分。
- 2
- 3
- 4
同一研究组用仿真讨论随机性在晋升中的作用,方法与目标论文相近。
读抓仿真设定与随机晋升最有效的结论。
- 5
同一研究方向的仿真,比较随机策略与技术策略的表现。
读抓仿真设定与随机策略的结果。
- 6Talent vs Luck: the role of randomness in success and failure
仿真显示最成功的人往往只是运气最好。
读抓模型设定:才能服从正态分布、运气事件随机出现,以及财富如何演化为幂律。
HN 书评
推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及“Instead of wasting time on a (rather biased) critique, read the original paper:”
“There is this interesting paper that evaluates role of luck and talent in outcome.”
“This parameter (no. of big lucky/unlucky events) diminishes the role of talent in the simulation.”
“The paper has no discussion, no justification for its parameters”
“This is a good example: Talent vs Luck”
看全部 15 条 →
“it amounts to nothing more than someone creating a model of the world as they think it is”
“It could very well be luck: Talent vs Luck”
“In fact, according to research[0], the most successful are usually not the most talented, but those of mediocre talent and a lot of luck.”
“so much of success is due to luck and network effects in addition to hard work and talent”
“there was a paper this year that won an Ig Nobel prize, which made the case that promotions are awarded at worse-than-random”
“Ref: Talent vs Luck ("Talent vs. Luck: The Role of Randomness in Success and Failure")”
“I have provided links below to help you improve and evolve this model.”
“Ref: arxiv.org/abs/1802.07068: Talent vs. Luck: The Role of Randomness in Success and Failure Talent vs Luck”
“Ref: Talent vs Luck”
- Talent vs. Luck: the role of randomness in success and failure ↗kwikiel · 2018-03-01 · 5 分
- Talent vs. Luck: the role of randomness in success and failure ↗DyslexicAtheist · 2018-03-02 · 2 分
- Talent vs. Luck: the role of randomness in success and failure ↗metafunctor · 2018-03-03 · 2 分
- Talent vs. Luck: the role of randomness in success and failure ↗okket · 2018-03-04 · 1 分
- Talent vs. Luck: the role of randomness in success and failure ↗mmrezaie · 2018-03-06 · 100 分