批评dhx · 2012-09
“In figure 2, the paper [3] tries to fit the data to an exponential curve starting at 2004. The longer term data at [2] does not appear to support this fit.”
全球粮价越过阈值后,抗议与骚乱更容易爆发
论文发现 2011 年北非和中东暴力抗议以及 2008 年更早的骚乱,在时间上都与全球粮价的大幅峰值吻合,并识别出一个粮价阈值,超过后抗议很可能发生。作者还发现粮价存在持续上涨的趋势,外推后认为即使没有价格峰值,也会在 2012–2013 年进入高冲击区间,并主张需要迅速而协调的行动来避免全球粮食危机。
评论者用它说明粮价冲击可能引发抗议或政治动荡;也有人批评其从 2004 年起拟合指数曲线的做法,认为更长期的数据并不支持。
“In figure 2, the paper [3] tries to fit the data to an exponential curve starting at 2004. The longer term data at [2] does not appear to support this fit.”
“some people have noticed that food price changes can lead to revolts [1]”