批评lisper · 2019-09
“I'm just now working my way through his paper but I'd be very surprised if it did not also have some untenable assumption hidden in there somewhere.”
从自定位不确定性出发,论证多世界诠释中必须采用玻恩规则
多世界(Everett)诠释长期的难题是:为什么概率等于振幅的平方,即玻恩规则的来源。论文指出,在波函数因退相干而分支、到观察者记录结果之间,观察者处于自定位不确定性之中,作者主张不能把各分支视为等概率。借助与 Zurek 的 envariance 推导类似的方法,并只依赖“仅改变环境不影响局部子系统测量结果概率”这一条原则,论证玻恩规则是在多世界诠释下分配信念度的唯一理性方式。
评论者把它当作论证多世界诠释下概率必须是玻恩概率的尝试来引用,也有人读后怀疑其中藏着站不住脚的假设。
“I'm just now working my way through his paper but I'd be very surprised if it did not also have some untenable assumption hidden in there somewhere.”
“In fact the month of May saw three papers by major physicists about these deeper issues in QM [1,2,3]”
“it would provably have to be the Born probability (see Self-Locating Uncertainty and the Origin of Probability in Everettian Quantum Mechanics)”