按年被提到
20142020 · 6 次2026
物理与量子›量子基础与物理哲学·arXiv:1405.1548 · quant-ph

The Cellular Automaton Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

量子力学的元胞自动机诠释
Gerard 't Hooft · 2014

't Hooft 主张量子力学只是分析底层经典元胞自动机的工具

开始阅读 ↗PDFalphaXiv 讨论
被推荐 · 11 人首次 2014-06-30 · 最近 2022-07-09发表于 Fundamental theories of physics
11不同的人
11活跃月份
13讨论串
355被引(OpenAlex)

't Hooft 在这部专著式的长文中主张:量子力学应被看作一种工具而非终极理论,其底层可能是经典、确定性的元胞自动机,标准模型与引力原则上也可被视为对这类经典系统的量子式分析。他论证这一图景可与 Bell 定理相容,并设法克服对「超决定论」的常见反对意见,从而消解坍缩问题和测量问题,并为时间之箭给出更简洁的解释。

HN 为什么提它

HN 上的人把它当作「量子力学可由确定性元胞自动机涌现、超决定论」这一思路的代表文献,常围绕它能否被量子计算机(如运行 Shor 算法)证伪展开争论,也有人认为它多半是错的。

观点难度 5 / 5约 600 分钟经得起时间
读之前最好知道
1量子力学(Hilbert 空间与算符)
2Bell 定理(Bell's theorem)
3元胞自动机(cellular automata)
4超决定论(superdeterminism)
5量子测量问题(measurement problem)

学习路径

读这篇之前,按顺序读书架上的 1 篇 · 参考文献来自 OpenAlex,顺序和要点由 Claude Code 排出

候选里只有一篇与 't Hooft 的思路直接相关:全息原理的科普阐述,帮你理解他在底层物理上的思考方式。

  1. 1
    The World as a Hologram作为全息图的世界 · 1994

    阐释 't Hooft 提出的全息原理,是他对底层离散自由度看法的背景。

    读抓信息与面积成正比、三维世界可由二维数据编码的论点。

  2. 2
    The Cellular Automaton Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics量子力学的元胞自动机诠释 · 2014 · 就是这篇

    主张量子力学只是描述底层经典元胞自动机的数学工具。

    读先读引言里对哥本哈根诠释的不满与本体态(ontological states)的说法,再读元胞自动机模型与叠加的解释。

HN 书评

推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及
推荐wolfgke · 2017-01

“Relevant for those who are interested in the topic:”

推荐 't Hooft 这篇用元胞自动机诠释量子力学的论文给感兴趣的人
The Trouble with Quantum Mechanics原评论 ↗
推荐wolfgke · 2017-06

“Then read "The Cellular Automaton Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics" by Gerard 't Hooft”

推荐读 't Hooft 这篇,用离散元胞自动机构建超决定论量子力学
What Is Mathematics and What Should It Be? [pdf]原评论 ↗
推荐not_kurt_godel · 2019-10

“I think you'd probably be interested in Gerard 't Hooft's latest work: The Cellular Automaton Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics”

推荐 't Hooft 的最新工作,用确定性元胞自动机框架诠释量子力学
I’m Convinced We Found Evidence of Life on Mars in the 1970s原评论 ↗
批评wolfgke · 2017-01

“which the Nobel laureate Gerard 't Hooft worked on for the last years is probably wrong.”

Fake Physics原评论 ↗
引用abdullahkhalids · 2014-06

“In fact the month of May saw three papers by major physicists about these deeper issues in QM [1,2,3]”

把它列为五月三篇探讨量子力学深层问题的论文之一
Fluid Tests Hint at Concrete Quantum Reality原评论 ↗
引用miltondts · 2017-01

“Actually the kind of superdeterministic theories proposed by t'Hooft are falsifiable.”

指出 't Hooft 提出的这类超决定论理论是可证伪的
The Trouble with Quantum Mechanics原评论 ↗
看全部 16 条 →
引用goldenkey · 2017-04

“Even QM can be emergent from deterministic automata.”

拿它说明量子力学甚至可以从确定性自动机中涌现
A Computer Scientist’s View of Life, the Universe, and Everything (1999)原评论 ↗
引用miltondts · 2019-03

“EDIT: See page 79 of the referenced paper for the detailed argument.”

补充指引看该论文第 79 页,了解量子计算机能否证伪 CAT 的详细论证
Arrow of time and its reversal on IBM quantum computer (2018)原评论 ↗
引用mikhailfranco · 2019-10

“while (as usual) 't Hooft pursued his physics intuitions to create a candidate CA theory:”

指出 't Hooft 凭物理直觉提出了一个元胞自动机理论候选
Wolfram Rule 30 Prizes原评论 ↗
引用Grieverheart · 2020-03

“see e.g. The Cellular Automaton Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics [OTHER_PAPER]”

引用它作为量子力学的元胞自动机诠释,一种超决定论模型
Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis in physics原评论 ↗
引用miltondts · 2020-03

“it seems to me that the CAT is falsified;”

认为若工程师造出运行 Shor 算法的量子计算机,CAT 就被证伪
Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis in physics原评论 ↗
引用skosch · 2020-03

“Gerard t'Hoofts framing of the universe as a cellular automaton is relatively intuitive, but still only a rough sketch.”

提到 't Hooft 把宇宙看作元胞自动机,较直观但仍只是粗略草图
Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis in physics原评论 ↗
引用zakk · 2020-04

“Quantum Mechanics described in terms of cellular automata [0].”

引用它,用元胞自动机来描述量子力学
The Wolfram Physics Project原评论 ↗
引用miltondts · 2020-04

“if that is the prediction then they are in good company.”

认为该理论预言量子计算机不会比经典计算机更高效,并说这并不孤立
The Wolfram Physics Project原评论 ↗
引用T-A · 2020-10

“In principle, you could also imagine a classical (i.e. deterministic) theory along the lines of (2), but I can't think of any example which comes close to actually doing the job.”

借 't Hooft 的确定性诠释说明经典理论难有接近成功的例子
Einstein's description of gravity just got much harder to beat原评论 ↗
引用miltondts · 2022-07

“If engineers ever succeed in making such quantum computers, it seems to me that the CAT is falsified; no classical theory can explain quantum mechanics.”

指出若造出量子计算机,元胞自动机理论就被证伪,经典理论无法解释量子力学
Einstein-Bohr debate settled once and for all原评论 ↗
被提交为 story · 1 次