按年被提到
20142015 · 3 次2026
天文、太空与生命›生命起源与费米悖论·arXiv:1410.5787 · q-fin.GN

The Precautionary Principle (with Application to the Genetic Modification of Organisms)

预防原则(及其在转基因生物中的应用)
Nassim Nicholas Taleb, Rupert Read, Raphael Douady, Joseph Norman, Yaneer Bar-Yam · 2014

Taleb 等用肥尾与系统性风险形式化预防原则,并主张严格限制转基因

开始阅读 ↗PDFalphaXiv 讨论
被推荐 · 9 人首次 2014-11-09 · 最近 2023-10-18
9不同的人
8活跃月份
8讨论串
45被引(OpenAlex)

文章提出非天真的预防原则(PP):把预防限定在特定领域和问题上,以避免偏执和瘫痪。作者把 PP 放进「毁灭问题」的统计与概率结构,用基于脆弱性的方法替代风险,并区分薄尾与肥尾、局部与系统性风险,把 PP 置于肥尾加系统性的情形。他们认为转基因生物会带来全球性危害的公共风险(而核能的危害相对有限且更易刻画),因此 PP 应当用于对转基因施加严格限制。

HN 为什么提它

HN 上的人把它当作支持预防原则、质疑转基因安全共识的论据来引用;也有评论批评其写作不连贯,并认为它关于转基因会不受控扩散的假设不成立。

观点难度 3 / 5约 60 分钟经得起时间
读之前最好知道
1概率论与肥尾分布(fat tails)
2风险与毁灭问题(ruin problem)
3黑天鹅与脆弱性(fragility)概念
4转基因生物(GMO)基础

HN 书评

推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及
推荐binarypaean · 2018-03

“Taleb et al captured the nebulous fears many people have around GMOs fairly rigorously”

称 Taleb 等人较严谨地刻画了人们对转基因的模糊担忧
Why I’m quitting GMO research原评论 ↗
推荐jk2323 · 2018-04

“May I recommend an article by Taleb:”

推荐 Taleb 这篇论证不确定性下预防原则的文章
EU agrees on total ban of bee-harming pesticides原评论 ↗
批评bluecalm · 2015-07

“His writing is incoherent though.”

The Mathiness of Nassim Nicholas Taleb原评论 ↗
批评danieltillett · 2015-12

“The problem with this analysis is their assumption that GMOs have a propensity to spread uncontrollably. This is totally false.”

Brazil declares emergency after 2,400 babies are born with brain damage原评论 ↗
引用pella · 2014-11

“"The Precautionary Principle (with Application to the Genetic Modification of Organisms)" The Precautionary Principle (with Application to the Genetic Modification of Organisms)”

引用它把预防原则用于转基因,以反驳安全共识
The Unbelievable Skepticism of the Amazing Randi原评论 ↗
引用tiatia · 2015-12

“The Precautionary Principle (with Application to the Genetic Modification of Organisms)”

引用它作为转基因释放风险论证的依据
Brazil declares emergency after 2,400 babies are born with brain damage原评论 ↗
看全部 8 条 →
引用grzm · 2016-11

“That PDF in turn references "The Precautionary Principle (with Application to the Genetic Modification of Organisms)" from 2014.”

指出某份 PDF 又引用了这篇 2014 年的预防原则论文
We’re Scientists, Moms, And We Avoid Non-GMO Products原评论 ↗
引用jayalpha · 2018-12

“Taleb also advocates the precautionary principle:”

指出 Taleb 也主张预防原则,并附上此文
Deformities Alarm Scientists Racing to Rewrite Animal DNA原评论 ↗
被提交为 story · 1 次