按年被提到
20182020 · 14 次2026
天文、太空与生命›生命起源与费米悖论·arXiv:1806.02404 · physics.pop-ph

Dissolving the Fermi Paradox

消解费米悖论
Anders Sandberg, Eric Drexler, Toby Ord · 2018

用参数不确定性的分布取代点估计,说明费米悖论不足为奇

开始阅读 ↗PDFalphaXiv 讨论
被推荐 · 36 人首次 2018-06-13 · 最近 2026-09-12
36不同的人
29活跃月份
41讨论串
29被引(OpenAlex)

论文指出费米悖论源于 Drake 类方程对高度不确定的参数隐含地当作确定值来用。作者结合生命起源路径上化学与遗传转变的模型,表明现有科学知识对应的不确定性跨越多个数量级;把模型改写为真实的不确定性分布后,宇宙中没有其他智慧生命的先验概率相当可观,因此没有观测到任何迹象并不令人意外。

HN 为什么提它

HN 上的人在讨论费米悖论和大过滤器时反复提它,用它说明相乘点估计会得出误导性结果、应该对分布做卷积,并称它比大过滤器之类的解释更有说服力、而且好读。

观点难度 2 / 5约 45 分钟经得起时间
读之前最好知道
1Drake 方程
2概率分布与不确定性传播(uncertainty propagation)
3蒙特卡洛方法(Monte Carlo)的基本概念
4费米悖论的背景

学习路径

读这篇之前,按顺序读书架上的 1 篇 · 参考文献来自 OpenAlex,顺序和要点由 Claude Code 排出

这条路径补上贝叶斯视角下生命起源概率的不确定性,再读如何用参数分布消解费米悖论。

  1. 1

    用贝叶斯分析讨论地球上生命早期出现对生命起源概率的含义,说明参数不确定性对结论的影响。

    读抓先验如何左右结论、早期出现能提供多少信息。

  2. 2
    Dissolving the Fermi Paradox消解费米悖论 · 2018 · 就是这篇

    用参数不确定性的分布取代点估计,说明费米悖论不足为奇。

    读抓 Drake 方程各参数取分布后,乘积分布的形状与无生命概率。

HN 书评

推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及
推荐skybrian · 2018-08

“Here's a more rigorous argument that was published recently:”

推荐近期发表的更严谨的论证,消解费米悖论
Why we downplay Fermi’s paradox原评论 ↗
推荐thaumaturgy · 2019-03

“A good paper on this from last year: Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf]”

推荐它,讲 Drake 方程的不确定性如何消解费米悖论
Galaxy Simulations Offer a New Solution to the Fermi Paradox原评论 ↗
推荐the8472 · 2019-06

“this great paper that highlights how much information”

推荐它,说明完整概率分布保留了点估计丢失的信息
End-User Probabilistic Programming [pdf]原评论 ↗
推荐disconcision · 2020-12

“the most convincing meta-analysis i've seen”

称其为见过最有说服力的元分析,估计我们孤独的概率 39%-85%
A Statistical Estimate of Extraterrestrial Intelligence in the Milky Way Galaxy原评论 ↗
推荐shiftingleft · 2021-01

“This explanation is much more plausible than a Great Filter.”

认为这种解释比 Great Filter 更合理
The Great Filter – Are We Almost Past It? (1998)原评论 ↗
推荐Pazzaz · 2021-01

“An interesting paper that I don't see brought up often enough”

推荐这篇少被提起的论文,我们孤独的概率约 39%
Once we can see them, it’s too late原评论 ↗
看全部 20 条 →
推荐the8472 · 2021-05

“Dissolving the Fermi Paradox[0] is a great and easy to read paper”

称其好读,用概率分布取代 Drake 方程的点估计
60 years later, is it time to update the Drake equation?原评论 ↗
推荐Symmetry · 2021-07

“One paper on the Fermi Paradox I want to plug is this one by Sandberg, Drexler, and Ord.”

特别推荐这篇费米估算分析,认为智慧文明可能稀少
Beyond “Fermi’s Paradox” XVI: What Is the “Dark Forest” Hypothesis?原评论 ↗
推荐theptip · 2022-10

“Compare with this recent paper that actually analyzes the individual genetic evolution steps required:”

拿它作对比,它用蒙特卡洛处理 Drake 方程的不确定性
Grabby Aliens: A Resolution to the Fermi Paradox原评论 ↗
推荐OisinMoran · 2025-04

“If you enjoy the write up, you might be interested in the paper”

推荐给喜欢该文章的人,概率密度相乘显示我们可能孤独
Show HN: Unsure Calculator – back-of-a-napkin probabilistic calculator原评论 ↗
引用jerf · 2018-06

“This should go straight to the PDF: Dissolving the Fermi Paradox”

给出可直达 PDF 的链接,arXiv 无需登录
Dissolving the Fermi Paradox原评论 ↗
引用ndethore · 2018-07

“a paper that demonstrate a substantial probability that we're alone our galaxy”

引它说明银河系中人类孤独的概率相当大
Ask HN: Is there any credible evidence for ET intelligent life?原评论 ↗
引用Tuna-Fish · 2019-10

“And the year before that gave us Dissolving the Fermi paradox[1], which conclusively shows that the drake equation is not worth the napkin it's written on.”

拿它说明 Drake 方程不值一张餐巾纸
Planetary 'autopsies' indicate worlds like Earth common in the cosmos原评论 ↗
引用hindsightbias · 2020-05

“When we update this prior in light of the Fermi observation, we find a substantial probability that we are alone in our galaxy, and perhaps even in our observable universe (53%–99.6% and 39%–85% respectively).”

引用其结论:我们在银河系中孤独的概率相当大
Japan to Draw Up UFO Encounter Protocols After U.S. Footage原评论 ↗
引用pmohun · 2020-05

“You may have seen this resolution to the Fermi Paradox”

把它当作费米悖论的一种解答:Drake 方程的不确定性
Timeline of the Far Future原评论 ↗
引用IngoBlechschmid · 2020-05

“Apparently there is also a easy solution to the Fermi paradox by taking the uncertainty in the Drake parameters into account:”

拿它说明考虑 Drake 参数的不确定性就能解释费米悖论
Growing Anomalies at the Large Hadron Collider Raise Hopes原评论 ↗
引用jtolds · 2020-09

“The Drake equation is malformed; multiplying expected values is a bad way to combine probability distributions.”

批评 Drake 方程把期望值相乘来组合概率分布
Phosphine detected in the atmosphere of Venus – an indicator of possible life?原评论 ↗
引用cb321 · 2020-09

“There is this Dissolving the Fermi Paradox”

引它说明不确定项相乘会使费米悖论消失
Lattice Confinement Fusion原评论 ↗
引用yyyk · 2020-09

“It turns out that when taking into account all known factors, us being alone is a nontrivial possibility:”

引它说明考虑所有已知因素后,我们孤独并非不可能
First Evidence of a Planet in Another Galaxy原评论 ↗
引用TTPrograms · 2021-03

“The Fermi Paradox is not real if you consider the massive uncertainty we have on the parameters of the Drake equation:”

引它论证 Drake 参数极不确定,费米悖论并不成立
Grabby Aliens原评论 ↗