引用nullify88 · 2019-09
“Here's a whitepaper that did some benchmarks and a detailed analysis on it.”
贴出做了基准测试的白皮书,显示 DoH 和 DoT 加载网页可比 UDP DNS 更快
实测加密 DNS(DoH、DoT)与传统 DNS 的查询和页面加载耗时
论文从五个全球观测点测量传统 DNS(Do53)、DNS-over-TLS 与 DNS-over-HTTPS 对查询响应时间和页面加载时间的影响。结果显示 DoH、DoT 的单次响应通常更慢,但页面加载时间可能优于 Do53;在吞吐下降、丢包和延迟增加时 Do53 加载最快,且 Do53 与 DoT 的页面成功加载率高于 DoH。作者据此提出机会性部分响应、线格式缓存等改进建议。
HN 评论者在讨论加密 DNS 是否更慢时引用它,作为 DoH/DoT 页面加载有时反而不输传统 UDP DNS、并在丢包网络下表现各异的实测依据。
“Here's a whitepaper that did some benchmarks and a detailed analysis on it.”
“On the lossy 4G network, DoT grows increasingly faster than Do53, and DoH begins to close the gap.”
“And here are some measurements from Hounsel et al. Comparing the Effects of DNS, DoT, and DoH on Web Performance”