“I came across Scott Aaronson's review of NKS a few days ago and loved it: Book Review.”
Book Review: 'A New Kind of Science'
Aaronson 对 Wolfram《新科学》的批判性书评
对 Stephen Wolfram 的《一种新科学》做批判性书评,不逐章评价,而聚焦计算复杂性和基础物理两个方面。在复杂性方面用理论计算机科学的标准方法回应 Wolfram 提出的一些问题;在物理方面检验他提出的量子力学之下的确定性模型,其中用“长程线”连接纠缠粒子,并证明该方案无法同时与狭义相对论和贝尔不等式违反相容。
每当 Wolfram 的理论或新项目被讨论,评论者就拿它当礼貌但有力的反驳:其确定性元胞自动机模型无法满足贝尔不等式违反,并称这一点早在 20 年前就被指出。
HN 书评
推荐在前,同类按时间 · 每篇最多保留 20 条,统计用全部提及“Scott Aaronson wrote good professional critique where he just politely debunked the main points of the book.”
“Scott Aaronson did: [1], [2]”
“i do like the feynman quote at the top of Book Review which was linked to above”
“Ah, here we go. Aaronson 2002 shows that Wolfram's model cannot be consistent with experimental evidence:”
“See Book Review”
看全部 12 条 →
“Wolfram's theory was already very politely but firmly shown to be wrong 20 years ago, by people who took a look into it. Scott Aaronson for example.”
“Here is one breakdown: Book Review”
“Scott Aaronson gave some issues with it being cellular automata even with threads connecting them”
“But Wolfram had been accused of this sort of thing before, see e.g. Book Review”
“Scott Aaronson review [0] and Cosma Shali's review [1] of NKS kinds of points to this direction, so he may well be a fraud.”
“Here are two recent critiques of this work”
- Review of Stephen Wolfram’s Book a New Kind of Science by Scott Aaronson (2002) ↗weinzierl · 2015-10-23 · 1 分